perm filename AUTOMA.2[F75,JMC]1 blob
sn#191100 filedate 1975-12-11 generic text, type T, neo UTF8
00100 CONCEPTS DEFINED RELATIVE TO A THEORY
00200
00300
00400 Our idea is that the philosophical difficulties in explicating
00500 certain concepts, especially counterfactuals and concepts involving
00600 counterfactuals, arise from the fact that the concept cannot be
00700 defined in terms of the world itself, but only in terms of a theory.
00800 In spite of this, the concepts can be quite useful. We shall
00900 illustrate this with an example described in terms of automata.
01000
01100 Let %2A%1 be a discrete automaton perhaps indeterminate.
01200 Suppose that %2A%1 has a very large number of states say 2↑10↑25
01300 as is reasonable for a human. We are interested in how this
01400 automaton changes with time, but we are not interested in the
01500 exact state which is unobservable, but only in certain functions
01600 of the state. Some of hese are observable, but we are not afraid
01700 to be interested in some unobservable functions provided there
01800 is good evidence for them. Let us lump these functions together
01900 by forming a vector to get a single function %2f(s)%1 where %2s%1
02000 denotes the state of %2A%1. We can consider the values of %2s'%1
02100 to be the states of a new automaton %2A'%1 which will usually
02200 be highly indeterminate. Namely,